Berlin, Germany

I will be in Berlin, Germany, for the next week viewing the Museum of Ethnography’s collection and recording data. Today, I met with Dr. Peter Bolz and we discussed how hobbyists of American Indian culture emerged in Germany.

The exhibit that Dr. Bolz has put together of the perception of Native American peoples by Europeans is incredibly interesting. He traces what he believes is the genesis of the hobbyists through early lithographs and photography in the 1830s-1890s. Works by these artists have been placed side-by-side to show that certain props were used to make the photograph more pleasing to the photographer’s audience. This early photography has been used by present-day hobbyists to replicate regalia.

Karl May was a turn-of-the-century German author who created the character of Winnetou. Although presently believed to be on the decline in Germany, the popularity of Karl May’s books has lasted until just recently. From these books have emerged a cult following, the German hobbyists, who participate in special powwows put on throughout the year in Germany. These hobbyists dress up in the replicated regalia of Plains Indian style dress and camp out in tipis by the hundreds. Several hobbyists meticulously research beadwork and quillwork patterns in museums throughout Europe to ensure that they have the finest and most accurate representation of American Indian culture in the 19th century. They see themselves as self-appointed preservation officers that protect Native American culture and art from this time period and fully reject the notion of modern-day tribal culture. 

Hobbyists also exist in America. Instead of manifesting in the way it has in Germany in “powwows with no Indians,” it has come about in a different way; through non-profit organizations that use the names of tribes and who have no ancestral connection to Native American peoples. Within American Indian circles, these groups are referred to as “wannabe’s.”

“So what?” someone asked, “they aren’t hurting anyone.” Well, the fact of the matter is that this is very harmful. Aside from the profit seeking motives that are self-evident, the representations  of American Indian people by hobbyists in both Germany and the United States is damaging to public perceptions of Native Americans. Because neither Germany nor the United States teaches Native American history and current events in the public education system, many children and influential leaders believe that 21st century Native American people either do not presently exist or exist as they did one-hundred or more years ago. Sadly, this is a failing of our education system.

Although standardized testing is extremely controversial, the incorporation of Native American history and current events would assist in addressing this failing. The states of Washington and New Mexico have incorporated Federal Indian Law as subjects in their state bar examinations. As a result, more students take Federal Indian law classes each year and have exposure to some of the most pressing issues in Indian country. This, in turn, has built awareness among attorneys in both states and helpful legislation has been passed. Similarly, the inclusion of Native American history and current events in standardized testing would force the education of students in this subject and make our country’s children and future leaders more aware of the present-day issues faced by our tribes and tribal members.    


3 thoughts on “Berlin, Germany”

  1. First, I must say, this is genius! I found this blog yesterday and I think my heart skipped a beat. I will be traveling to Europe in July (this year) and will be researching Native North American collections (personal research but also on be half of my tribe). I would love it we could chat further! Keep up the great work. Look forward to hearing from you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. ~ Hidonee


    1. Hidonee–I just sent you a message via email, but please feel free to post what you learn while abroad if you’d like to do so. This is meant to be an open forum for tribes to discuss issues surrounding international repatriation, as well as a centralized location for information about international Native American collections. Anything is helpful. Good luck and safe travels!


  2. I visited one of the ethnological museums, the one in Dahlem, Berlin and recently wrote about it. They had an exhibit of modern Native American arts which I was curious to see if it was only interpretation of natives by others. It was delighted to find it solely consisted of native artists, however I was chilled by a display in another area of the museum which I found in very poor cultural taste and boarded being offensive, especially in that it was also inaccurate.

    It is rather telling, as you mention in your article, that because of either misrepresentation or a kind of romantification/villification process that seems to suggest we are extinct, I receive regular search terms to my blog: “Are there any American Indians in Europe?” or either, “Are there any American Indians anymore?”


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s